• <tr id="yyy80"></tr>
  • <sup id="yyy80"></sup>
  • <tfoot id="yyy80"><noscript id="yyy80"></noscript></tfoot>
  • 99热精品在线国产_美女午夜性视频免费_国产精品国产高清国产av_av欧美777_自拍偷自拍亚洲精品老妇_亚洲熟女精品中文字幕_www日本黄色视频网_国产精品野战在线观看 ?

    經(jīng)由中國的比較研究:論竹內(nèi)好對魯迅的解讀和武田泰淳對司馬遷的解讀

    2022-02-09 10:19:51石井剛東京大學(xué)
    國際比較文學(xué)(中英文) 2022年3期
    關(guān)鍵詞:東京竹內(nèi)全集

    石井剛 東京大學(xué)

    Historical Narrative without Eschatology

    Takeuchi Yoshimi竹內(nèi)好(1908-1977)was not satisfied with Takeda Taijun’s武田泰淳(1912-1976)masterpieceSima Qian司馬遷(Shiba Sen,1943)as he found that this work lacked an eschatological view of history.Instead of a vertical chronological history,Takeda depicted a horizontal one that provided a spatial recognition of world history,lacking an eschatological view in the end.According to Takeuchi,this shortage can be attributed to Takeda’s literary style and philosophy.Takeuchisays:

    InSima Qian,the idea of the continuing worldview by which he switches a temporal continuity into a spatial one turns out to be a theory of historical narrative.However,I have to point out that the prototype of this idea originally lurks in Takeda’s identity as a writer.I had written an essay before,in which I said that his writing lacks Japanese taste.This characteristic of his writing style was molded out of the characteristic of his philosophy.1(日)竹內(nèi)好:《『武田泰淳全集』第9巻解説》,《竹內(nèi)好全集》第12巻,東京:筑摩書房,1980年,第161頁。[Takeuchi Yoshimi,“Takeda Taijun zenshūdai 9 kan kaisetsu”(A Commentary on the Complete Works of Takeda Taijun,vol.9),in Takeuchi Yo‐shimi Zenshū(The Complete Works of Takeuchi Yoshimi),vol.12,Tokyo:Chikuma shobō,1980,161.]Translation mine.

    Takeuchi complained about Takeda’s lack of an eschatological view because it showed a lack of a revolutionary prospect in Chinese history.Therefore,if this lack could be attributed to Takeda’s writing style and thought,we may argue that for Takeuchi,Takeda was not entirely sympathetic to the Chinese Revolution.The lack of Japanese taste,originally“wabun chō”(he wendiao和文調(diào))in Japanese,naturally means that Takeda’s writing has a much more classical Chinese taste.Wabun chōmust be juxtaposed withkanbun漢文,or classical Chinese writing.Hence,Takeuchi’s criticism of Takeda’s literature is targeted at classical Chinese writing,which was still dominating Sinologyin Japan.

    It is difficult to imagine that Takeuchi was not aware that Takeda drew a clear image of the end of the world,although it was not necessarily an eschatology.Takeda’s well-known essay,“On the Extinct”(Metsubōni tsuite滅亡について,1948),is one of the most significant works worth reading together withSima Qian,wherein Takeda demonstrates his apocalyptic imagination.In this essay,Takeda mentioned that there were two types of extinctions:one partial and the othertotal.Takedastates:

    The true meaning of the extinct is no more than total extinction.The nature of it can be depicted as the whole extinction with sulfur,fire,smoke,poisonous beasts,and venomous snakes.Compared with this major extinction,extinctions in reality are smaller.This fact provides extinguishing people with consolation.As only two atomic bombs were dropped on the Japanese land,we are still alive in the world.It gives a condition for Japanese people to restart.If dozens were dropped,there would have only been silent ashes remaining.Then,regardless of sorrows,regrets,or democratization,nothing could have been meaningful.A very limited extinction of Japan,or the existence of something remained,means survival without being digested.From the view of theworldas an organic system,these remainders might be a sort of disgusting,sinewy food.2(日)武田泰淳:《滅亡について》,《武田泰淳全集》第12巻,東京:筑摩書房,1972年,第94頁。[Takeda Taijun,“Metsubōni tsuite”(On the Extinct),in Takeda Taijun Zenshū(The Complete Works of Takeda Taijun),vol.12,Tokyo:Chikuma Shobō,1972,94.]

    Literally,the extinct is total.The temporal view would be like a scene of theApocalypse.However,it seems that Takeda does not want to define this as the end of the world.“Sulfur,fire,smoke,poisonous beasts,and venomous snakes”are assorted things that would bring about extinction and dominate the world after the extinction.This means that the extinction is not necessarily about the whole world.The extinction is always meant for certain specific entities,but not for the world as a whole.SinceTakeda imagines the world as an organic body,the extinction of a people or a state on ly means the process of digestion and nutrition by the world:

    The world itself understands its own necessity of metabolism very well.Hence,for it,the disappearance of some individuals and peoples in its body is not a phenomenon that renders it depressed or gloomy.3Ibid.

    Along with this notion,the so-called extinctions,in most cases,are partial ones,while the total ex tinction of the whole world is not coming. Furthermore,Takeda says that the reason why the worldhas maintained its life so far is that it has experienced partial extinctions regularly. The total or thetrue extinction,then,by his definition,is almost impossible,let alone eschatological.An eschatol ogy is only meaningful when the end of the world brings a messianic message. If that is the case forTakeda,who rejects an eschatological narrative of history,is there any room for messianism in histhought?In“On the Extinct,”he does not neglectto respond to this inquiry:

    TheJātaka,a southern Buddhist text,records three warnings raised before Buddha’s advent.The first is the extinction that would be carried out by heavenly people who belong to the world of desire.4Ibid.,96.

    TheJātakais a text compiling episodes on Bodhisattva’s goodness in saving people.According to Takeda,Bodhisattva was regarded as a previous incarnation of Buddha.TheJātakasays that the world experienced extinction before Buddha was born.In other words,the world where we live now is one after extinction,as Buddha had already gone away a long time ago.It reveals thatall of us are already salvaged from the very beginning of history.Therefore,it does not seem strange thatTakeda’s thought lacks an eschatological view of history. However,in contrast to Takeuchi’s opin ion,the lack of eschatology was not necessarily Takeda’s weak point;rather,this lack itself is an in dispensable element of his worldview. He once dreamed of cultural restoration emerging from a ru ined park when he was in China,where he was dispatched as a soldier. His experience at the sitesdevastated by Japanese military operations,where he was involved,also provided him with anidea of how culture emerges. For him,who believed that human culture emerged from ruin,theidea of the world ending would be unacceptable.5(日)武田泰淳:《支那文化に関すtf手紙》,《武田泰淳全集》第11巻,東京:筑摩書房,1971年,第243頁。[Takeda Taijun,“Shina bunka ni kansuru tegami”(A Letter on Chinese Culture),in Takeda Taijun Zenshū(The Complete Works of Takeda Taijun),vol.11,Tokyo:Chikuma shobō,1971,243.]

    LuXun and Modern Chinese Revolution for Takeuchi Yoshimi

    Intriguingly,Takeuchi Yoshimi attributes Takeda’s lack of eschatology to a lack of Japanese style in his writing.But for Takeda,Takeuchi’s writing appeared too modernized,or too sympathetic to the Chinese Revolution.In his postscript for Takeuchi’sLu Xun(Rojin魯迅),written in 1944,Takedawrites:

    I have been a good friend of Mr.Takeuchi for more than ten years.I hope I will be a thinker whom Takeuchi appreciates.But I am also afraid that I will fail to be one whom he dislikes.Perhaps there are few youths in China who would feel happy to be the ones whom Lu Xun dislikes.It is,however,difficult to be one whom Lu Xun would appreciate.6(日)武田泰淳:《竹內(nèi)好『魯迅』跋》,《武田泰淳全集》第11巻,東京:筑摩書房,1971年,第377頁。[Takeda Taijun,“Takeuchi Yoshimi Rojin batsu”(APostscript for TakeuchiYoshimi’s Lu Xun),in Takeda Taijun Zenshū(The Complete Works of TakedaTaijun),vol.11,Tokyo:Chikuma shobō,1971,377.]

    Takeda adopts the classical Chinese writing style to write this postscript,which accompaniedLu Xun’s first version.After completing this masterpiece,Takeuchi was sent to China as a drafted soldier.When he later looked back on the sentiment,Takeuchi said that writing this work was like writing his last will.We can detect a kind of ambivalence in Takeda’s thoughts on Takeuchi’s literature and on Lu Xun魯迅(1881-1936),a representative of Chinese modernization,although Takeda praises the work.Takeda expresses his expectation that because the author put his heart and soul into tackling Lu Xun,who was a“gigantic Other confronting him,”7Ibid.,vol.12,277.Takeuchi’s work would become a starting point for young literary researchers who would devote themselves to studies of Lu Xunand Asian Literature.

    To summarize the characteristics of Takeuchi’sLu Xun,it is nothing other than the“awareness of being a slave.”It is the painful and fearful awareness of“no way to go forward,”as though one is awakened from comfortable sleep in an iron room that has neither a door nor a window.Lu Xun decided to play the role of a wise man to enlighten people in the iron room to open the door for Chinese modern literature.According to Takeuchi,however,Lu Xun’s decision could never lead to the liberation of slaves.Slaves would reject being slaves,but at the same time,they would also have to reject the liberation,for the liberationisillusory.Takeuchisays:

    Though there is no way to go,one has to move forward.Nay,one must move forward just because there is no way to go.That was the situation[in which Lu Xun’s literature began].He rejected being himself,but at the same time,he was also rejected by someone else.This is the meaning of the desperation that constitutes Lu Xun’s literature.Desperation appears as resistance insofar as one must move forward where there is no way to go.Resistance appears as an act formed by desperation.As a state,it is desperation.As a motion,it is resistance.Here there is no room for humanism.8(日)竹內(nèi)好:《中國の近代と日本の近代》,《日本とアジア》,東京:筑摩書房,1993年,第41頁。[Takeuchi Yoshimi,“Chūgoku no kindai to Nihon no kindai”(Chinese Modernity and Japanese Modernity),in Takeuchi Yoshimi,Nihon to Ajia(Japan and Asia),Tokyo:Chikuma Shobō,1993,41.]

    Although in his“My Old Home”(Guxiang故鄉(xiāng)),Lu Xun says that“hope cannot be said to exist,nor can it be said not to exist.It is just like roads across the earth.For actually the earth had no roads to begin with,but when many men pass one way,a road is made”9Lu Xun,“My Old Home,”in Call to Arms,trans.YANG Xianyi and Gladys Yang(Beijing:Foreign Languages Press,1981),65..Takeuchi pays more attention to another desperate notion expressed in a famous phrase from Sandor Petofi,as quoted by Lu Xun: “Desperation is as illusory as hope.”Therefore,if we could find some possibility forhope,the way only to see it would beto despair of desperation.However,it seems that Takeuchi intends to reject anyway to find hope,ashiswritingappearsnihilistic:

    The only way for someone who has despaired of desperation is to be a writer.Without relying on anyone,without support from anything,he has to possess everything.Lu Xun as a writer was born in this way.10(日)竹內(nèi)好:《魯迅》,東京:未來社,1961年,第129頁。[Takeuchi Yoshimi,Rojin(LuXun),Tokyo:Miraisha,1961,129.]

    To be a writer means to be a resister.Nevertheless,the word“resist”here has little to do with the courageousness that usually comes to mind.Lu Xun,in his depiction by Takeuchi Yoshimi,strongly refused humanism.This image would haunt Takeuchi when he discussed Japan.He argues that Japanese modernization was a process similar to that of a slave liberating the mself to become the master.It means that the Japanese people rejected being themselves and rejected resisting as well.A slave is the same as a master of the slave because they equally reject identifying themselves as slaves.Takeuchi holds that there could never be a possibility of Japanese people having a thinker like Lu Xun.By the same token,it is possible to say that China was almost destined to generate Lu Xun.For Takeuchi,Lu Xun is identified with Chinese culture,which Takeuchi utilizes in turn as a means to criticize Japanese culture.Of course,China is not always ideal for him.He admits that“Lu Xun was isolated in Chinese literature.”11(日)竹內(nèi)好:《中國の近代と日本の近代》,op.cit.,46.[Takeuchi Yoshimi,“Chūgoku no kindai to Nihon no kindai”(Chinese Modernity and Japanese Modernity),in Nihon to Ajia(Japan and Asia),46.]Nevertheless,Takeuchi believed that Lu Xun’s isolation is recognized because he is within Chinese culture.Both the Xinhai Revolution in 1911 led by Sun Yat-sen孫中山(1866-1925)and the Communist Revolution led by Mao Zedong毛澤東(1893-1976)successfully inherited something from Chinese culture,an inheritance also shared by Lu Xun.In short,Lu Xun for Takeuchi is a figure who attempted to overcome the worldview expressed in classical Chinese language to create a new modern China with his desperate resistance to the pre-modern culture.The May Fourth Movement,claiming to overthrow Confucianism,wasthe very expression of such an effortto modernize China.

    For Takeuchi,the success of the Communist Revolution led by Mao Zedong realized China’s modernization.The moral stance of the Communist Party of China(CPC),which took modernization forward,is determined by its nature as“a total anti-traditionalist”party.12(日)竹內(nèi)好:《日本人の中國観》,《竹內(nèi)好全集》,東京:筑摩書房,1980年,第11頁。[Takeuchi Yoshimi,“Nihonjin no Chūgokukan”(The Image of China for Japanese People),in Takeuchi Yoshimi Zenshū(The Complete Works of Takeuchi Yoshimi),Tokyo:Chikuma shobō,1980,11.]In his“The Image of China for Japanese People”(Nihonjin no Chūgokukan日本人の中國観)written in 1949,the same year the People’s Republic of China was founded,Takeuchi writes:

    If you look at the generating process of modern consciousness in China in terms of their confrontation with tradition,you will find that this stream had been constantly flowing with a serious denial of past authorities,or simply,Confucianism.Firstly,the Neo-Confucianism of the Song dynasty was denied;secondly,exegesis in the Han dynasty was denied;at last,they denied deifying Confucius.These sequential denials were completed at last in the May Fourth cultural movement,which was seen as the turning point of the modern period.AsOn New Democracy[by Mao Zedong]puts it,the May Fourth Movement was the source of the revolutionary energy that directly led to CPC’s current movement.13Ibid.,10-11.

    This narrative of sequentially denying“past authorities”is in keeping with Liang Qichao’s梁啟超(1873-1929)thesis of“l(fā)iberation with restoration”from his 1921Introduction to the Scholarship of the Qing Dynasty(Qingdai xueshu gailun清代學(xué)術(shù)概論).However,Takeuchi goes one step further to see that the aforesaid revolutionaries accomplished the denial of“deifying Confucius”in the Chi nese Revolution by themselves,while Liang shows his regret about the bad habit of“modeling af ter great predecessors”repeated throughout the intellectual history of China. For Liang,the histori cal trend of“l(fā)iberation with restoration”generated in Qing scholarship is key to the modernizationof Chinese scholarship;he juxtaposes this trend in the Qing period with the Renaissance in theWestern world,which accomplished modernization by restoring the Greek humanism tradition.However,Liang could not be satisfied with a mere restoration,as it means that people still utilizetheir predecessors as their models to move forward. Without overcoming such a dependence onpast authorities,he argues,it is not possible to realize true scientific spirit. Liang regards Confu cius as the center of those past authorities. Takeuchi,however,has a different view on the historyof Chinese modernization;he clearly says that the de-deification of Confucius was carried out inthe May Fourth Movement. Intriguingly,in the 1920s,after coming back from a long journey inEurope,Liang Qichao diverted his thought toward revaluating Confucian values. Due to this intel lectual change,Liang was reappraised as a master of national learning in the 1990s,when the clas sical turn of intellectuals became an intellectual trend,thanks to the massive economic growth inEast Asian nations,including the marketization of China beginning in the 1990s. It is obvious thatclassical values,represented by Confucianism,have undergone a revival in China in the past de cades.Takeuchi’s judgment of Mao’s revolution as a major achievement of Chinese modernizationmust be re-examined from today’s viewpoint.Things will appear more complicated if we pay moreattention to Takeuchi’s understanding of the Chinese tradition.When he says that the“denial of past authorities”in Chinese historical development is an“expression of the radical innate energy,”he was aware of the complicated implication of the word“tradition”as descriptive of Chinese intellectual history.Takeuchi argues that the CPC managed to be“a total anti-traditionalist”party,not because they destroyed traditions in a radical sense,but because the denial of tradition itself is deeply rooted in the Chinese tradition.14Ibid.,11.The conclusion is ironic:The revolutionary history constituting the foundation of the People’s Republic of China is not simply a denial of past cultures,but an inher itance of the tradition insofar asthe tradition is self-negating.This kind of irony may be representedby Lu Xun’s literature of“awareness of being a slave,”in Takeuchi’s terms. The tradition in Chi nese history,for Takeuchi,is none other than the manifestation of the literary attitude of Lu Xun,who tried to resist the situation of moving forward with no way to go,who tried to resist being aslave as well as the liberation from the identity of a slave. Needless to say,Japanese modernizationis on the opposite side,as it denies admitting its state of being a slave while pursuing institutionaldevelopments.

    How,then,does Takeuchi evaluate Japanese modernization?In the same essay,he says that he was“struck by a miserable sentiment”when he learned that Kōtoku Shūsui幸徳秋水(1871-1911),an anarchist thinker executed for suspicious treason in 1911,agreed with Nakae Chōmin中江兆民(1847-1901),a distinguished progressive philosopher known as“the Oriental Rousseau,”that educational reforms should be implemented to nourish virtues according to“the way of Confucius and Mencius.”15Ibid.,15.Why was Takeuchi shocked?It was not because he refused Confucianism,which after all was overthrown by the May Fourth Movement.What is at stake here is Takeuchi’s empha sison the necessity of theindependenceof Japaneseculturefrom China:

    To get rid of Japan’s contempt of China,it is necessary for Japanese culture to become independent from Chinese culture.16Ibid.,16.

    Takeuchi states that Japanese people still look down upon China even after Japan’s defeat in World War II.For him,even progressive intellectuals such as Maruyama Masao丸山真男(1914-1996)were not innocent in this regard.Takeuchi referred to the view of China held by John Dewey,who stayed in China during the May Fourth Move men tin1919 afterhe visited Japan:

    According to Dewey,Japan effortlessly succeeded in introducing European technology because the pressure of its tradition was weak;eventually,it preserved its old culture.China fell behind in modernization due to the strong reaction from its tradition;hence its reforms were more thorough,and eventually they managed to establish a radical basis for reforming the national mind.17Ibid.,13.

    Here,borrowing Dewey’s observation,Takeuchi depicts Japanese modernization and its attempt to escape slavery to become the master.Perhaps we can say that Japan’s“old culture”can be juxtaposed with the“historical old substratum”in Maruyama Masao’s sense.However,Takeuchi might not agree with Dewey.Takeuchi insists that Japanese people,unlike Chinese people,do not have their own cultural products;rather,their innate habits cause them to learn from and imitate others.18Ibid.,14.Takeuchi regards it as“miserable”that even Nakae and Kōtoku,the two most progressive figures in Meiji Japan,still insisted that traditional thoughts borrowed from China should constitute the moral basis of modern Japan.What is the right way,then,for Japanese people to modernize themselves,just as the Chinese people succeeded in modernization?How should Japanese people tackle the lack of a clear direction to go with their“self-awareness of being a slave”?Apossible answer is that they must consider Japan’s tradition as the nation’s moral basis,instead of borrowing a foreign tradition,such as“the ways of Confucius and Mencius.”Historically,Motoori Norinaga本居宣長(1730-1801)had tried to go in this direction during the Edo period.However,it is difficult to imagine that Takeuchi would have intended to follow him.Takeuchi admits that“Japanese culture has never been independent even in the past or today,while the problem is to construct our own independent culture in the future.”19Ibid.,15.Indeed,this reminds us of Takeda Taijun’s opinion inSi?maQian.

    The World in the Records of the Grand Historian

    In the postscript to the first version ofSima Qianpublished in 1943,Takeda refers to the decentralizing nature of theRecords of the Grand Historian(Shiji史記)to conclude that the world depicted in this work makes him“uneasy.”Takeda criticizes Sima Qian(145BC-86BC)for constructing a worldview that appears“extremely disloyal”to Japanese people,who“believe that Japan is the center of the world.”20(日)武田泰淳:《司馬遷》,《武田泰淳全集》第11巻,東京:筑摩書房,1971年,第113頁。[Takeda Taijun,“Shiba Sen”(Sima Qian),in Takeda Taijun zenshū(The Complete Works of Takeda Taijun),vol.11,Tokyo:Chikuma shobō,1971,113.]Translation mine.Takedawrites:

    To believe Japan is the center while you are aware of yourself being in the world depicted in theRecords of the Grand Historian:This is what loyalty means.Not to be fearful even if you are nakedly in the world depicted in theRecords of the Grand Historian:That is what courage means.The asymmetry between loyalty and courage shows an attitude of a man who dares to go forward even though he knows that he is surrounded by the world depicted in theRecords of the Grand Historian.21Ibid.

    Noticing thatSima Qianwas published in 1943,we can imagine the specific historical background,namely Japan’s war against the US,which at the time was already unfavorable for Japan.Takeda says that he wrote this postscript with“envy”toward“the faithful young pilots who flew over Pearl Harbor.”22Ibid.

    The historical narrative in theRecords of the Grand Historianstarts from the“Basic Annals”(benji本紀),namely the chronological history of ancient kings and emperors.According to Takeda’s interpretation,Sima Qian thought it necessary for human history to establish the center of the world.In short,the“Basic Annals”are located at the center of world history.However,history inevitably betrays one’s desire to settle a center.The real history witnessed by Sima Qian deviated from the notion of centralization.The notion of an unbroken lineage of emperors set at the center of the world is typically expressed in the Japanese emperor system established in the Constitution of the Empire of Japan.In a sense,we might say that Takeda intends to write the story for the sake of demonstrating the inexorable failure of the Japanese emperor system.

    The“Basic Annals”soon encounter a deadlock where a single emperor’s line splits,showing the inevitable contradiction between the desire to establish a center in and for history,on one hand,and how history unfolds,on the other.The deadlock comprises the“Basic Annals of Xiang Yu項羽(232-202BC).”Needless to say,Xiang Yu competed with Liu Bang劉邦(?-195BC),tthe found ing emperor of the Han dynasty,to conquer the world and was defeated by Liu Bang,eventually be coming the only protagonist figure of the“Basic Annals,”although he was not an emperor. Thus,the narrative of theRecords of the Grand Historianis—as pointed out by Takeda—as complicated ashuman astronomybecause of Xiang Yu’s presence,which meant two“suns”—Liu and Xiang—appeared in the world simultaneously.The Basic Annals are followed by other genres including the“Hereditary Houses”(Shijia世家)and the“Ranked Biographies”(Liezhuan列傳),where we can see various human dramas taking place one after another.Such a decentralizing process,with proliferating complexity,of thishuman astronomydepicted in theRecords of the Grand Historian of the GrandHistorianleaves no room for eschatology in TakeuchiYoshimi’s view.

    Takeda’s worldview is also expressed in his“On the Extinct,”where he argues that“a line for non-extinction”is maintained in a partial extinction.23(日)武田泰淳:《滅亡について》,Takeda,op.cit.,95.[Takeda Taijun,“Metsubōni tsuite”(On the Extinct),in Takeda Tai‐jun Zenshū(The CompleteWorks of TakedaTaijun),vol.12,95.]Achapter of the“Tables”(Biao表)in theRe?cords of the Grand Historianreveals such a spatial and horizontal continuity of the world.How,then,istheend of thisdecentralized,horizontally continuousworld depicted?

    The Problem of“Xiongnu”

    In the last chapter of theRecords of the Grand Historian,Sima Qian wrote on the world of Xiongnu匈奴.The world depicted in theRecords of the Grand Historianbetrays the author’s attempt to set up the center of the world,but the text eventually comprises a much more complicated human universe,which Takeuchi calls a spatially,absolutely continuous world.The spatial continuity in theRecords of the Grand Historianextends from the territorial border of the Han Empire to its outside,namely the area occupied by Xiongnu.The people living a nomadic life in the Gobi and grasslands outside of the Great Wall threatened the Han Empire while they interpenetrated each other with no regard to political or economic concerns.In“The Problem of Xiongnu,”Sima Qian’s last chapter,Takeda Taijun describes the relationship between the Han Empire and Xiongnu as follows:

    Xiongnu is not merely barbarian.They have their own world totally in conflict with the Han Empire in terms of culture and life.Moreover,from Xiongnu to Han,from Han to Xiongnu,people and commodities are constantly moving and flowing.As a Han general may surrender to Xiongnu,so does a Chanyu[the title of Xiongnu rulers]as well.When Xiongnu suffered a political disturbance in their society,Han also got disturbed,and vice versa.Although they are confronting each other as two different worlds,a disturbance on one side always influences the other.24(日)武田泰淳:《司馬遷》,op.cit.,107.[Takeda Taijun,“Shiba Sen”(Sima Qian),in Takeda Taijun zenshū(The Complete Works of TakedaTaijun),vol.11,107.]

    Xiongnu was another world for the Han people;however,it is inescapable for Sima Qian to write about them because of their interactive relationship.They were two parts of the same world.Xiongnu people had their way of life and culture different from those of the Han people,but it was impos sible to conclude if the Xiongnu culture was inferior or superior.

    Our major concern is to think about Takeuchi’s criticism of Takeda,according to whichSima Qianlacks an eschatological worldview.The problem of Xiongnu provides crucial clues for thinking about it.At the end of“The Problem of Xiongnu,”Takeda summarizesSima Qian’s long story asfollows:

    Unconcealable sadness.Sima Qian kept his eyes on the Xiongnu problem with unconcealable feeling of sadness.

    What he witnessed with sad feeling was not only this problem,but also the whole world.25Ibid.,112.

    How should we understand these two short paragraphs?If Xiongnu inSima Qianis an analogy of China for Takeda,as Isoda Kōichi磯田光一(1931-1987)says,then what kind of“sadness”did Takeda feel?Let us see how Isoda understands the issue:

    Takeda is the only talent in Japan who is able to write on the Chinese Revolution in the very way in which he wroteSima Qian.However,without anguish in his heart,he probably cannot make full use of his genius.[...]The“China that should have been”is Jesus Christ for Takeda Taijun.In other words,it is something thatshould exist just because it does not ex?ist.I am somehow attracted by him who is seemingly reluctant to talk on the Chinese Revolution.26(日)磯田光一:《非革命者のキリスト——武田泰淳論——》,《増補武田泰淳研究》,東京:筑摩書房,1980年,第173~174頁。[Isoda Kōichi,“Hi kakumeisha no kirisuto——Takeda Taijun ron——”(Jesus Christ for Non-Revolutionaries:On Takeda Taijun),in Zōh(huán)o Takeda Taijun kenkyū(An Enlarged Edition of Researches on Takeda Taijun),Tokyo:Chikuma shobō,1980,173-74];emphasis added.Translation mine.

    Isoda likens Takeda to Judas Iscariot and compares China,or Mao Zedong,to Jesus Christ.Adapting this comparison to the analogy of the relationship between Han and Xiongnu as compared to the relationship between Japan and China,we might establish an analogy between Xiongnu and Jesus.Is that possible?In the postscript to the 1943 version ofSima Qian,Takeda shows regret that the world depicted in theRecords of the Grand Historianmade him feel uneasy.If we agree with Isoda,then,it would be clear that for Takeda,Jesus is the world in theRecords of the Grand Historian;otherwise,it is very difficult for us to understand why Takeda feels“uneasy.”Therefore,it seems inadequate to compare Xiongnu to Jesus as Isoda does.We cannot narrow down the realm of this world into Xiongnu’sworld,but in reality,if we follow Isoda in seeing Takeda as a Judas,who betrayed Jesus,then the world depicted in theRecords of the Grand Historianas a whole,including both Han and Xiongnu,shouldbeJesusfor Takeda.

    Consequently,the world in theRecords of the Grand Historianfrom which Takeda draws a totalizing picture rejects providing salvation.Takeuchi keenly and correctly points out that Takeda’s world lacks an eschatological view.For Takeda,China is not the Messiah at all.We have to recall the way he beginsSima Qian:“Sima Qian is a man who lived in shame.”27(日)武田泰淳:《司馬遷》,op.cit.,5.[Takeda Taijun,“Shiba Sen”(Sima Qian),in Takeda Taijun zenshū(The Complete Works of TakedaTaijun),vol.11,5.]In reality,Takeda lived in shame as a drafted soldier dispatched to China from 1937 to 1939.He assimilated himself to Sima Qian,who was sentenced to be castrated because of a speech defending Li Ling李陵(?-74BC),a general who failed to conquer Xiongnu and was eventually captured by them.For Sima Qian,writing history was the only way to soothe his feelings of shame.By the same token,for Takeda,drawing a totalizing picture from the de-centralized,spatially continuous world of Sima Qian’s writings was the only way to live in his shame.Their praxes as writers were not for the sake of seeking salvation,insofar as they were all excluded from the opportunity for salvation. Giving up the hope of sal vation is their common point from the very outset when they both decided to write.

    Takeda could not stand upon the basis on which TakeuchiYoshimi applauded China’s revolutionary history from Lu Xun to Mao Zedong.He could not stand with the Japanese people either,who still wanted to maintain their loyalty to the notion of the center,even though the world depicted in theRecords of the Grand Historiangradually came to actualize after 1941.ThoughSima Qianwas repeatedly reprinted after World War II,the postscript in which Takeda emphasized the significance of the Japanese spirits of loyalty and courage has been deleted.Before the publication of theComplete Works of Takeda Taijun(Takeda Taijun zenshū武田泰淳全集)in 1980(after his death in 1976),it had been a forgotten secret of Takeda’s literature for a long time.

    In short,the“sadness”expressed by Takeda at the end of“The Problem of Xiongnu,”is derived from the unerasable distance between the world in theRecords of the Grand Historian—a decentralized,absolute,unenclosed world—and himself.However,the absolute openness of the world could be enclosed only when Xiongnu got involved in it.Xiongnu was an indispensable element in the world ofRecords of the Grand Historian.At least,they were the“inner others”in the world.Therefore,Takeda,who witnessed it with“sadness,”must also be included in the same world.WritingSimaQian,hechallenged Sima Qian’sworldview butwasdefeated atlast.

    Takeda’s“shame”was not erased but strengthened.For example,in an article published in 1947,he portrays himself as one of“theYin殷people.”28(日)武田泰淳:《『経書の成立』と現(xiàn)実感覚》,《武田泰淳全集》第12巻,東京:筑摩書房,1972年,第56頁。[Takeda Taijun,“Keisho no seiritsu to genjitu kankaku”(The Birth of Confucian Classics and the Sense of Reality),in Takeda Taijun Zenshū(The Complete Works of TakedaTaijun),vol.12,Tokyo:Chikuma Shobō,1972,56.]The article was written to review Hiraoka Takeo’s平岡武夫(1909-1995)Birth of Confucian Classics(Keisho no seiritsu経書の成立).Hiraoka,a professor of Chinese philosophy and literature at Kyoto University,elaborates how the Zhou周Kings accomplished the dynastic transition from theYin dynasty through establishing a new world view of“all-under-heaven, tianxia天下.According to Hiraoka,the Zhou Kings utilized a novel concept of tian天(heaven)to legitimate their sovereignty in order to successfully establish a new feudal state system that replaced the clannish rule of the Yin dynasty.The term“all-underheaven,”commonly used by EastAsian nations to indicate the world,was coined for the first time.Under the rule by kings representing heaven,the Yin clan was allowed to survive as a feudal lordship.All-under-heaven as a world system would potentially include everything whatsoever.It would be an unenclosed system in its ideal.Being Yin people under the Zhou dynasty naturally meant living their lives after their political extinction.Although,at the same time,they would have more motivations to defend the value of heaven just because they were not able to enjoy a good reputation among their contemporary neighbors.As the Records ofthe Grand Historian suggest,Confucius is also one of the Yin people’s descendants.The reason Confucius had such a strong will to restore the ideal ritual and music established by the Zhou dynasty could be explained according to this background.Takeda also identifies himself with the Yin people defeated by heavenly will.His feeling of“sadness”can be heard as an echo of theYin people’s grief and Confucius’s struggle with his existential crisis in a harsh reality.

    Eschatology for Takeuchi

    What about Takeuchi,then?As we have already examined,he emphasizes that Japan has to admit“that Japanese culture has never been independent in the past or present”;thus,Japan has to make efforts to construct its own independent culture in the future.To do so,he rejects learning from Confucius or Mencius,just as the May Fourth intellectuals did.However,this is not the path on which people could go forward.At least,Takeda gave up going along this path,as he deleted the postscript from post-war versions of Sima Qian.Since Takeuchi was a loyal follower of Lu Xun,the path on which people cannot go forward became just the path he had to take.This attitude appears opposite to Takeda.Even if Takeuchi feels“uneasiness”in a confrontation in the world of Re?cords of the Grand Historian just like Takeda,does he also feel“sad”?The answer is perhaps“no.”Moreover,hasTakeuchi ever noticed that the ways of Confucius and Mencius were originally generated by Yin descendants,and as a result,Confucianism is indeed a philosophy that has the potential to upset rulers by disturbing the world order with a view of what politics should be?In the Re?cords,Sima Qian depicts Confucius,who traveled through countries successively,as a“stray dog.”Confucius and his disciples wandered the world with no settled home in order to persuade feu dal lords to embrace the rituals and music established by the Zhou founders,although they werejust outsiders. Their image as wandering nomads is far from the usual image of Confucianism.They are more similar to Xiongnu than Han in Takeda’s writing,people who lived in a differentworld from the mainstream but raised innumerable conflicts with the Han people. Like the world in theRecords of the Grand Historian,the all-under-heaven world is a world of the inter-penetratingand inter-dependent relationship with one another and with the outsiders’world.

    Indeed,Takeda lacks an eschatological view. But for people who have to survive extinction,eschatological salvation has no room from the very beginning. Takeuchi also criticizes Takeda’swriting for its lack of Japanese taste. This is also correct. Takeda prefers to identify himself as a“stray dog”and a disgraced historian. His Chinese style of writing is the natural consequence ofsuch an identification.

    Then again,Takeuchi devotes himself to the Chinese modernity represented by Lu Xun’s literature and manifested by the Communist Revolution led by Mao.His sympathy toward Chinese modernization,however,sometimes shows a kind of contradiction.For a typical instance,we know well his 1941 article“The Greater EastAsia War and Our Resolution”(Dai Tōa sensōto ware?ra no ketsui大東亜戦爭と吾等の決意).In this article,he praises Japan’s declaration of war against the US.I think this is not a mistake that young Takeuchi made,but an expression of the same desire to praise the Communist Revolution led by Mao after World War II.Unlike his selfidentification as a man who deeply understands China,Takeuchi is much more distanced from the world of China,at least from the China that he imagined,where there is always a distinct“center”of tradition,morality,and resistance.China,or the all-under-heaven world,has already gone far beyond eschatology because itincludes countless extinctions in its spatially continuous history.

    Takeda might say that if Takeuchi still has a chance to be saved,salvation will take place only by way of negating salvation.As Takeuchi strongly embraces Chinese literature,he fails to understand that another China still exists after the revolution,a China that had already experienced extinctionsmany times.

    猜你喜歡
    東京竹內(nèi)全集
    嚴復(fù)全集
    東京之夜
    視野(2017年23期)2017-12-26 21:17:44
    上海人民出版社 章太炎全集
    東京
    東京
    東京通信
    竹內(nèi)實和他的《詩人毛澤東》
    《陳望道全集》出版
    明星開心笑果全集等
    不是竹內(nèi)實,是竹內(nèi)好
    讀書(1996年8期)1996-07-15 05:30:10
    午夜激情欧美在线| 91久久精品电影网| 有码 亚洲区| av在线蜜桃| 联通29元200g的流量卡| 性色avwww在线观看| 五月玫瑰六月丁香| 此物有八面人人有两片| 波多野结衣巨乳人妻| 亚洲欧美日韩高清专用| 国产男人的电影天堂91| 成人毛片a级毛片在线播放| 国产欧美日韩精品一区二区| 国产成人aa在线观看| 少妇的逼好多水| 日韩一本色道免费dvd| 国产成人一区二区在线| 99久国产av精品| av在线播放精品| 国产高清激情床上av| 伦理电影大哥的女人| 中文在线观看免费www的网站| 久99久视频精品免费| a级毛片a级免费在线| 人人妻,人人澡人人爽秒播| 日韩国内少妇激情av| 中文字幕人妻熟人妻熟丝袜美| 国产亚洲欧美98| 免费观看人在逋| 一进一出好大好爽视频| 精品人妻偷拍中文字幕| 国产在线精品亚洲第一网站| 非洲黑人性xxxx精品又粗又长| 欧美激情在线99| 高清日韩中文字幕在线| 亚洲乱码一区二区免费版| 国产成人精品久久久久久| 国产亚洲精品久久久久久毛片| 少妇的逼水好多| 国产精品永久免费网站| 老司机午夜福利在线观看视频| 国内精品宾馆在线| 久久韩国三级中文字幕| 麻豆国产97在线/欧美| 少妇丰满av| 欧美日本亚洲视频在线播放| 亚洲电影在线观看av| 国产亚洲精品av在线| 老女人水多毛片| 国产精品伦人一区二区| 有码 亚洲区| 波多野结衣高清无吗| h日本视频在线播放| 97超碰精品成人国产| 精品日产1卡2卡| 精品无人区乱码1区二区| 99久久无色码亚洲精品果冻| 亚洲国产欧美人成| 久久精品久久久久久噜噜老黄 | 成人综合一区亚洲| 干丝袜人妻中文字幕| 能在线免费观看的黄片| 搡老妇女老女人老熟妇| 狂野欧美激情性xxxx在线观看| 亚洲av美国av| 日韩中字成人| 中文字幕av成人在线电影| 精品福利观看| 成人精品一区二区免费| 欧美高清性xxxxhd video| 麻豆成人午夜福利视频| 搡老妇女老女人老熟妇| 国国产精品蜜臀av免费| 精品国产三级普通话版| 2021天堂中文幕一二区在线观| 国内精品美女久久久久久| 国产乱人偷精品视频| 国产欧美日韩一区二区精品| 在线观看午夜福利视频| 一夜夜www| 久久久精品欧美日韩精品| a级毛片a级免费在线| 精华霜和精华液先用哪个| 欧美+亚洲+日韩+国产| 亚洲精品日韩av片在线观看| 黑人高潮一二区| 一级毛片久久久久久久久女| 亚洲高清免费不卡视频| 国产精品不卡视频一区二区| 级片在线观看| 男人狂女人下面高潮的视频| 99久国产av精品国产电影| 亚洲精品久久国产高清桃花| 综合色av麻豆| 久久久久久久久久黄片| 美女免费视频网站| 2021天堂中文幕一二区在线观| 亚洲精品在线观看二区| 精品福利观看| 欧美不卡视频在线免费观看| 在线a可以看的网站| 婷婷精品国产亚洲av| 欧美最黄视频在线播放免费| 干丝袜人妻中文字幕| 日韩av在线大香蕉| 日韩欧美一区二区三区在线观看| 悠悠久久av| 18+在线观看网站| 国产探花在线观看一区二区| 午夜激情欧美在线| 免费看日本二区| 干丝袜人妻中文字幕| 亚洲一区高清亚洲精品| 国产日本99.免费观看| 欧美日韩乱码在线| 女生性感内裤真人,穿戴方法视频| 99热网站在线观看| av天堂在线播放| 免费在线观看影片大全网站| 看十八女毛片水多多多| 不卡视频在线观看欧美| 一级毛片aaaaaa免费看小| av黄色大香蕉| 最近手机中文字幕大全| 一a级毛片在线观看| 亚洲人成网站在线观看播放| 亚洲欧美清纯卡通| 久久精品国产自在天天线| 免费一级毛片在线播放高清视频| 欧美成人一区二区免费高清观看| 99国产极品粉嫩在线观看| 久久久a久久爽久久v久久| 亚洲av熟女| 亚洲成人中文字幕在线播放| 伦理电影大哥的女人| 一级av片app| 少妇的逼好多水| 精品人妻偷拍中文字幕| 18+在线观看网站| 成人性生交大片免费视频hd| 免费电影在线观看免费观看| 久久久久国产网址| 欧美色欧美亚洲另类二区| 欧美精品国产亚洲| 丰满人妻一区二区三区视频av| 日韩欧美三级三区| АⅤ资源中文在线天堂| 亚洲综合色惰| 免费不卡的大黄色大毛片视频在线观看 | 国产成人91sexporn| 国产极品精品免费视频能看的| 又黄又爽又免费观看的视频| 亚洲成人av在线免费| 国产精品不卡视频一区二区| 国产探花在线观看一区二区| 亚洲美女搞黄在线观看 | 亚洲三级黄色毛片| 欧美中文日本在线观看视频| 51国产日韩欧美| 一本一本综合久久| 久久午夜福利片| 欧美成人一区二区免费高清观看| 综合色丁香网| av在线播放精品| 一个人观看的视频www高清免费观看| 国产成人a∨麻豆精品| 亚洲精品国产av成人精品 | 国产免费男女视频| 国产探花极品一区二区| 日本成人三级电影网站| 91久久精品电影网| 色哟哟哟哟哟哟| 日本黄大片高清| 在线免费观看的www视频| 亚洲中文日韩欧美视频| 免费人成在线观看视频色| 日韩大尺度精品在线看网址| 久久人妻av系列| 女的被弄到高潮叫床怎么办| 久久久久性生活片| 麻豆乱淫一区二区| 日本黄色片子视频| 婷婷色av中文字幕| 九九爱精品视频在线观看| 男人狂女人下面高潮的视频| 亚洲成人一二三区av| 人人妻人人添人人爽欧美一区卜| 免费av中文字幕在线| 国产亚洲91精品色在线| 伊人亚洲综合成人网| 成年人免费黄色播放视频 | 秋霞伦理黄片| 一级毛片aaaaaa免费看小| 成人午夜精彩视频在线观看| 久久久精品免费免费高清| 九草在线视频观看| 色5月婷婷丁香| 久久久久国产网址| a级毛片在线看网站| 欧美精品人与动牲交sv欧美| 在线观看av片永久免费下载| 亚洲一区二区三区欧美精品| 日本色播在线视频| 亚洲av福利一区| 五月玫瑰六月丁香| 2018国产大陆天天弄谢| 有码 亚洲区| 99九九线精品视频在线观看视频| 欧美性感艳星| 18禁在线无遮挡免费观看视频| 99久久精品国产国产毛片| 国内精品宾馆在线| videossex国产| 国产乱来视频区| 亚洲国产成人一精品久久久| 久久精品国产亚洲av天美| 伊人久久国产一区二区| 在线观看一区二区三区激情| 国产成人午夜福利电影在线观看| 99re6热这里在线精品视频| 成年人免费黄色播放视频 | 赤兔流量卡办理| 人妻 亚洲 视频| 亚洲欧美日韩东京热| 亚洲av二区三区四区| www.av在线官网国产| 国产有黄有色有爽视频| 亚洲精品亚洲一区二区| 日本色播在线视频| av又黄又爽大尺度在线免费看| 偷拍熟女少妇极品色| 六月丁香七月| 韩国av在线不卡| 国产色爽女视频免费观看| 免费黄频网站在线观看国产| 国产伦精品一区二区三区四那| www.av在线官网国产| 天堂中文最新版在线下载| 亚洲激情五月婷婷啪啪| 国产精品偷伦视频观看了| 免费观看a级毛片全部| 97超视频在线观看视频| 欧美日韩视频高清一区二区三区二| 午夜91福利影院| 秋霞在线观看毛片| 免费黄网站久久成人精品| 日韩精品免费视频一区二区三区 | 成人美女网站在线观看视频| 秋霞伦理黄片| 亚洲国产毛片av蜜桃av| 亚洲av免费高清在线观看| 亚洲情色 制服丝袜| 亚洲欧洲国产日韩| av天堂中文字幕网| 亚洲精品中文字幕在线视频 | 国产伦精品一区二区三区视频9| 色网站视频免费| 大又大粗又爽又黄少妇毛片口| 人妻少妇偷人精品九色| 啦啦啦视频在线资源免费观看| 国产精品人妻久久久影院| 欧美日韩精品成人综合77777| 日日啪夜夜撸| 免费观看在线日韩| 黑丝袜美女国产一区| 亚洲欧美精品专区久久| 大码成人一级视频| 91精品国产国语对白视频| 精品国产一区二区三区久久久樱花| 久久人妻熟女aⅴ| 亚洲天堂av无毛| 少妇的逼好多水| 卡戴珊不雅视频在线播放| 一本一本综合久久| 丝袜在线中文字幕| 亚洲av成人精品一区久久| 伦精品一区二区三区| 亚洲欧美一区二区三区黑人 | 久久国产精品男人的天堂亚洲 | 男女国产视频网站| 六月丁香七月| 纯流量卡能插随身wifi吗| 国产毛片在线视频| 日本-黄色视频高清免费观看| 国产极品天堂在线| 日本wwww免费看| 国产精品一区二区在线不卡| 国产亚洲精品久久久com| 中文字幕免费在线视频6| 欧美+日韩+精品| 两个人的视频大全免费| av又黄又爽大尺度在线免费看| 美女内射精品一级片tv| 人妻系列 视频| 国产精品久久久久久久久免| 丰满少妇做爰视频| 一本一本综合久久| 人妻人人澡人人爽人人| a 毛片基地| 在线观看www视频免费| 青春草视频在线免费观看| 国产成人freesex在线| 国产免费一级a男人的天堂| 中文欧美无线码| 一级毛片久久久久久久久女| 毛片一级片免费看久久久久| 人妻少妇偷人精品九色| 在线观看一区二区三区激情| 看十八女毛片水多多多| 亚洲天堂av无毛| 在线观看美女被高潮喷水网站| 少妇人妻精品综合一区二区| 在线观看一区二区三区激情| 两个人的视频大全免费| 夫妻午夜视频| 在现免费观看毛片| 欧美一级a爱片免费观看看| 夜夜看夜夜爽夜夜摸| 菩萨蛮人人尽说江南好唐韦庄| 少妇猛男粗大的猛烈进出视频| 纯流量卡能插随身wifi吗| 少妇高潮的动态图| 久久国产乱子免费精品| 日韩强制内射视频| 麻豆乱淫一区二区| 久久亚洲国产成人精品v| 亚洲精品视频女| 欧美少妇被猛烈插入视频| 国产精品久久久久成人av| 亚洲国产精品国产精品| 亚洲中文av在线| av免费观看日本| 黄色怎么调成土黄色| 超碰97精品在线观看| 性高湖久久久久久久久免费观看| 精品一区二区免费观看| 简卡轻食公司| 一级毛片aaaaaa免费看小| 日本免费在线观看一区| 一区二区av电影网| av在线播放精品| 晚上一个人看的免费电影| 熟女av电影| 日日啪夜夜撸| 欧美少妇被猛烈插入视频| 简卡轻食公司| 久久国产精品男人的天堂亚洲 | 亚州av有码| 色婷婷久久久亚洲欧美| 高清在线视频一区二区三区| 亚洲国产精品999| 久久久午夜欧美精品| 国产亚洲91精品色在线| 精品一区二区三区视频在线| 亚洲三级黄色毛片| 欧美精品一区二区免费开放| 黑人猛操日本美女一级片| 亚洲国产色片| 久久国产精品男人的天堂亚洲 | 一级二级三级毛片免费看| 97精品久久久久久久久久精品| 国产色婷婷99| 国产永久视频网站| 久久久精品94久久精品| 欧美日韩av久久| 在线观看人妻少妇| av.在线天堂| 大码成人一级视频| 免费在线观看成人毛片| 成人午夜精彩视频在线观看| a级毛片在线看网站| 多毛熟女@视频| 久久精品夜色国产| 久久久精品免费免费高清| 最新的欧美精品一区二区| 亚洲精品国产成人久久av| 人妻系列 视频| 麻豆成人av视频| 免费高清在线观看视频在线观看| 色哟哟·www| 亚洲国产精品成人久久小说| 在线观看人妻少妇| 亚洲中文av在线| 最新中文字幕久久久久| 一本一本综合久久| 成人美女网站在线观看视频| 精品国产露脸久久av麻豆| 亚洲伊人久久精品综合| 热re99久久国产66热| 丁香六月天网| 日韩av不卡免费在线播放| 久久ye,这里只有精品| 国产精品久久久久久久久免| 亚洲av二区三区四区| 一本色道久久久久久精品综合| 亚洲国产精品成人久久小说| 欧美高清成人免费视频www| 亚洲精品日韩av片在线观看| 99久久综合免费| 午夜影院在线不卡| 汤姆久久久久久久影院中文字幕| 91久久精品国产一区二区成人| av在线app专区| 永久免费av网站大全| 91久久精品国产一区二区三区| 久久精品久久久久久久性| 一个人看视频在线观看www免费| 3wmmmm亚洲av在线观看| 亚洲婷婷狠狠爱综合网| 新久久久久国产一级毛片| 天堂中文最新版在线下载| 久久ye,这里只有精品| 亚洲不卡免费看| 国产精品一区二区性色av| 亚洲精品国产色婷婷电影| 免费看av在线观看网站| 欧美最新免费一区二区三区| 国产成人免费观看mmmm| av不卡在线播放| 97超碰精品成人国产| 国产永久视频网站| 欧美国产精品一级二级三级 | 两个人免费观看高清视频 | 精品久久久精品久久久| 午夜免费观看性视频| 男女边摸边吃奶| 偷拍熟女少妇极品色| 香蕉精品网在线| 黄色日韩在线| 九色成人免费人妻av| 欧美 日韩 精品 国产| 全区人妻精品视频| 亚洲欧洲精品一区二区精品久久久 | 久久韩国三级中文字幕| 亚洲精品乱码久久久v下载方式| 精品视频人人做人人爽| 人人妻人人澡人人爽人人夜夜| 午夜福利网站1000一区二区三区| 26uuu在线亚洲综合色| a级毛片免费高清观看在线播放| av国产久精品久网站免费入址| 国产精品一二三区在线看| 少妇精品久久久久久久| 在线精品无人区一区二区三| 日本-黄色视频高清免费观看| 色婷婷av一区二区三区视频| 一级毛片久久久久久久久女| 女性被躁到高潮视频| 精品亚洲成国产av| 欧美激情极品国产一区二区三区 | 亚洲成人av在线免费| 少妇被粗大猛烈的视频| 欧美性感艳星| 在线 av 中文字幕| 亚洲国产欧美日韩在线播放 | 草草在线视频免费看| 97精品久久久久久久久久精品| 成年人免费黄色播放视频 | 我要看日韩黄色一级片| 18禁动态无遮挡网站| 中文字幕人妻丝袜制服| 狂野欧美激情性xxxx在线观看| 丝袜在线中文字幕| 一级毛片黄色毛片免费观看视频| 一级片'在线观看视频| 51国产日韩欧美| 久久国产精品大桥未久av | 中文在线观看免费www的网站| 午夜久久久在线观看| 亚洲av.av天堂| 99热6这里只有精品| 免费看光身美女| 免费不卡的大黄色大毛片视频在线观看| 亚洲人与动物交配视频| 国产白丝娇喘喷水9色精品| 国产国拍精品亚洲av在线观看| 国产精品久久久久久精品古装| 精品国产露脸久久av麻豆| 狂野欧美激情性xxxx在线观看| 高清毛片免费看| 日韩一本色道免费dvd| 毛片一级片免费看久久久久| 人妻 亚洲 视频| 18禁裸乳无遮挡动漫免费视频| 亚洲成人一二三区av| 国内少妇人妻偷人精品xxx网站| 国产av国产精品国产| 国产精品不卡视频一区二区| 午夜激情久久久久久久| 精品亚洲乱码少妇综合久久| 国产精品偷伦视频观看了| 99久久精品国产国产毛片| av有码第一页| 天堂8中文在线网| 国产又色又爽无遮挡免| 97超视频在线观看视频| 久久99热6这里只有精品| 久久人妻熟女aⅴ| 久久99热这里只频精品6学生| h视频一区二区三区| 少妇人妻久久综合中文| 国产精品久久久久久久久免| 国产免费一级a男人的天堂| 日韩成人av中文字幕在线观看| 国产淫语在线视频| 99热网站在线观看| 男人狂女人下面高潮的视频| 深夜a级毛片| 热re99久久精品国产66热6| 欧美精品一区二区大全| 日韩欧美精品免费久久| 国产伦在线观看视频一区| 菩萨蛮人人尽说江南好唐韦庄| 超碰97精品在线观看| 欧美xxⅹ黑人| 精品少妇久久久久久888优播| 亚洲精品一区蜜桃| 老司机影院毛片| 欧美另类一区| 亚洲精品乱码久久久v下载方式| 男女啪啪激烈高潮av片| 欧美日韩视频高清一区二区三区二| 久久精品国产亚洲网站| av福利片在线观看| 亚洲欧洲日产国产| 欧美丝袜亚洲另类| 国内少妇人妻偷人精品xxx网站| 亚洲欧美日韩卡通动漫| 久久av网站| a级毛片免费高清观看在线播放| 亚洲国产毛片av蜜桃av| 国产一区二区在线观看av| 亚洲精品成人av观看孕妇| 亚洲国产精品一区二区三区在线| 美女内射精品一级片tv| 久久精品国产亚洲av涩爱| 久久影院123| 日韩在线高清观看一区二区三区| 亚洲av成人精品一二三区| 另类精品久久| 最新的欧美精品一区二区| 丝袜脚勾引网站| 夜夜看夜夜爽夜夜摸| 毛片一级片免费看久久久久| 久久精品国产亚洲av涩爱| 狂野欧美激情性xxxx在线观看| 国产精品麻豆人妻色哟哟久久| 少妇人妻 视频| 亚洲av综合色区一区| 日韩av不卡免费在线播放| 中文字幕精品免费在线观看视频 | 看非洲黑人一级黄片| a级毛色黄片| 天天躁夜夜躁狠狠久久av| 2021少妇久久久久久久久久久| 看十八女毛片水多多多| 天堂8中文在线网| 伦精品一区二区三区| 成人18禁高潮啪啪吃奶动态图 | 高清不卡的av网站| 伦精品一区二区三区| 亚州av有码| 乱码一卡2卡4卡精品| 深夜a级毛片| 精品人妻熟女av久视频| 成年美女黄网站色视频大全免费 | 伦理电影免费视频| 国产淫语在线视频| 一级毛片 在线播放| 国产91av在线免费观看| 欧美日韩在线观看h| 亚洲人与动物交配视频| 久久99一区二区三区| 高清欧美精品videossex| 久久国产精品大桥未久av | 美女中出高潮动态图| 大片电影免费在线观看免费| tube8黄色片| 国产欧美另类精品又又久久亚洲欧美| 极品少妇高潮喷水抽搐| 99久久精品热视频| videos熟女内射| 亚洲自偷自拍三级| 精品一品国产午夜福利视频| 九色成人免费人妻av| 精品一品国产午夜福利视频| 高清av免费在线| 国产欧美日韩精品一区二区| 一边亲一边摸免费视频| 久久久精品免费免费高清| 色哟哟·www| kizo精华| 久久人人爽av亚洲精品天堂| 国产伦在线观看视频一区| 偷拍熟女少妇极品色| 亚洲,欧美,日韩| 亚洲,一卡二卡三卡| 亚洲国产日韩一区二区| 啦啦啦中文免费视频观看日本| 久久av网站| 偷拍熟女少妇极品色| 熟女av电影| 18禁在线播放成人免费| 中文资源天堂在线| 中国国产av一级| 亚洲欧美成人精品一区二区| 97在线视频观看| 在线观看免费视频网站a站| 2018国产大陆天天弄谢| 久久精品熟女亚洲av麻豆精品| 日韩av免费高清视频| 99久久精品一区二区三区| 精品久久国产蜜桃| 亚洲精品一二三| 久久青草综合色|